// you’re reading...

General

Blackwell vs. Strickland: In Healthcare, a stark contrast…

UPDATE, Joe C. does this better and in more detail here, go check it out. The same basic principles come shining through as well.

Two Ohio Blogger Lefties have gone on Record as deriding Ken Blackwell’s healthcare plan as plagiarizing or rewriting Stricklands plan. Another derides it as a massive new entitlement.

It is neither, in fact it is nothing less than gradually taking apart Medicaid and re-formulating in it in a way to provide and require 100% healthcare coverage for all Ohioans. This is exactly in line with the Reformist Ken Blackwell we conservatives know and love and in fact have been wondering where the hell that Blackwell has been for the last few months.

To address the plagiarization issue, a quick glance at the table below shows how laughable that allegation is. There are only a few points of commonality and on those the methods and principles are so far apart as to be in a different universe.

Things I’ve learned on this analysis.

-Blackwell wins on details and specifics provided, it isn’t even close.

-Stricklands plan is can basically be summed up as expansion of medicare, group purchasing, a preventive care initiative, more nurses, and broadband?!

-Importantly there is no healthcare bureaucracy or entrenched institutions threatened by Stricklands plan.

-Blackwells plan levels a loaded gun at the entire Ohio health care/medicaid system and says “reform” or else.

-The Massachusetts plan has deep conservative roots, although I will agree that implementation can be tricky. Please read this Heritage Foundation (yes, that Heritage foundation) report on the Mass plan and frequently misunderstood areas.

-The Blackwell plan has nothing less as a goal to replace medicaid with 100% required private insurance supplemented for the very needy who can’t afford the premiums. Someone please explain to me how that’s not conservative.

Please read the plan in its entirety, theres literally too much interesting there to comment on in just this one post.

In both scope and innovation, Blackwell’s plan will have a bigger impact in the lower income areas of the state.

If white collar and business owners grasp the full implications, they will find much to like in the plan.

To noone’s suprise I’m sure, the MSM has completely failed to grasp the implications of the Blackwell plan.

Also to my neverending amusement, howling liberals are screaming about the mandates. While I appreciate their newfound anger and hostility toward government mandates in at least one specific area, they might try applying that principal in other areas such as oh, let’s see Social Security?

Feature Strickland Blackwell
Government Reform

Blackwell will create the Ohio Health Financing Commission to coordinate health care policy and expenditures. …

The commission will supervise all state agencies involved in purchasing, providing and regulating the health care delivery system. It will be designated as the overall Ohio Medicaid agency to ensure it has supervisory authority over Ohio’s Medicaid program. The commission will be responsible for the critical relationship with federal Center for Medicaid Services programs, and seek waivers whenever necessary to implement programs.

Medicaid Reform

Upgraded IT systems

Better Audting

More Long Term Care financing and service choices.  Review of payment practices.

Transfer Medicaid patients to managed care systems (HMO’s)

Transfer all of Medicaid to a consumer directed private health care approach!!! (ed. I added the exclamations).

No manipulation of eligibility criteria, instead, a target of 100% private insurance.

Strict spending targets.

Health Exchange or Connector for Group Purchasing power for small groups and Individuals The Ohio Healthcare Exchange will be a free-market exchange for private health plans available to all Ohioans at low prices through the power of group purchasing.

The Buckeye Health Connection would match uninsured individuals with private health insurance coverage and facilitate those relationships as described below.

…last paragraph:

Also, Blackwell will seek to strengthen and modernize health care purchasing pools currently providing health care insurance to Ohioans. Consumer-driven purchasing groups should be given the opportunity to provide new forms of consumer-directed health care products, including health savings accounts.

Help for Medicaid Ineligible folks and the uninsured. Premium support will be available for the estimated 300,000 Medicaid-ineligible Ohioans making up to 150% of the federal poverty level ($30,000 annually for a family of four).

All Uninsured are required to be covered ala the Massachusetts Plan:

The Massachusetts plan starts from the fundamental premise that covering the uninsured
should be accomplished through the free market and not through expansion of a government
program, such as Medicaid. Accordingly, the Massachusetts plan is based upon the creation of a
new insurance marketplace, called the “Connector,” to match uninsured individuals with private
health insurance.
The Connector will not offer any health insurance coverage. However, the Connector
will allow each uninsured individual to create a personal account to accumulate health insurance
premium dollars.
The premium dollars will be derived from: (i) employer contributions (from employers
to 50 employees); (ii) employee contributions; and, (iii) to the extent determined by the State,
subsidies for low income individuals. The Connector will be structured to permit use of the IRC
125 deduction for health insurance costs permitting the coverages to be purchased with pre-tax
dollars. The dollars from all sources are combined in each individual’s account and the
individual selects a health insurance plan from a list of plans that will be “pre-approved” by the
Connector.

Additionally:

One immediate step would be to increase the age a young adult can remain on a family
insurance policy to 29.

Stated Budget Impact

A Strickland-Fisher Administration will seek a federal Medicaid 1115 Waiver to permit federal matching on spending to support the investment needed for this initiative. Combined with current state resources, this will generate sufficient funding to cover the cost of the entire program – totaling $550 million over the first two years. This will not take additional tax dollars from Ohio taxpayers, but will simply take advantage of available federal funding that the state of Ohio is not currently pursuing.

Funding for the Massachusetts plan will be drawn from three principle sources: (i)
transfer of current Medicare funding into the Connector pool to subsidize insurance; (ii)
individual contributions; and, (iii) an employer charge of $295 per employee on each employer
with 11 or more employees who refuses to cooperate with the requirements of the program (such

as setting up an IRC §125 cafeteria plan).

Marketing

Administration will aggressively reach out to eligible families and children to make certain that they are covered.

Medicaid for Disabled a Strickland-Fisher Administration will make changes so that Ohioans with severe disabilities have an opportunity to buy into the Medicaid program and continue to receive the specialized healthcare they need while working at a job that pays a living wage.
Pharmacies

The Commission made several important recommendations in this area, including: (i)
establishing an evidence-based drug formulary; (ii) consolidating all Ohio pharmacy purchases
into one purchasing group; (iii) consider joining a multi-state pharmacy purchasing consortium;
and, (iv) monitor the effectiveness of pharmaceutical regimes for patients.

Preventive Care

Healthy Ohio, an initiative to identify duplicative health and social services costs paid for with state dollars and incentivize health contractors to achieve specific health and social service benchmarks.

A Strickland-Fisher Administration will challenge Ohio’s families to play a role in Healthy Ohio by taking a larger responsibility in the healthcare decision-making process, focusing on preventive care and making appropriate, educated lifestyle choices.

&nb
More Nurses

Healthy Ohio initiative will work with Ohio’s healthcare and higher education communities to address the shortage of nurses by making clinical faculty jobs more competitive, and offering salary and other incentives to encourage trained clinical faculty to stay in Ohio and teach.

[more money for nursing colleges]

Broadband

A Strickland-Fisher administration will be dedicated to establishing a virtual space for health research, development, and care, putting Ohio’s healthcare institutions at the forefront of new information technologies and delivery systems. These include the use of electronic medical records, “real time” telemedicine, and other communication innovations. The presence of such a dedicated network will position Ohio companies well to compete for new federal programs devoted to the development of new healthcare information technologies.

The benefits of such technological capabilities are widespread including increased efficiencies, stabilizing healthcare costs, healthy outcomes, and enhanced delivery of care to currently underserved populations.

Discussion

Comments are disallowed for this post.

  1. Thanks Dave! for doing the heavy lifting.

    I look forward to reviewing your table later. (Skimmed the Heritage link. I have some residual anxiety about the pharmacy “group purchasing power”; but overall, I’m much happier than when I first saw summaries of Blackwell’s proposal.)

    Posted by Cornfed | August 28, 2006, 6:37 pm
  2. Sorry Dave, but count me as one conservative who does not like the government telling me what I must purchase. This is not why I support KB and I have great problems with this.

    Posted by Steven J. Kelso Sr. | August 29, 2006, 10:57 pm
  3. [...] bet.  Lets keep in mind that during the campaign we had a decent proposal from Blackwell that would have used the money that we’re already spending to solve 90% of the [...]

    Posted by NixGuy.com » HillaryCare Ohio-Style | September 20, 2007, 11:18 pm